Kaupmehe tn 7-120Kesklinna linnaosa, Tallinn10114 Harju maakondESTONIA
Originally published: February 2024 · Updated: December 2025
In 2025, most Shopify agencies still push one narrative: “You need a fully custom theme to grow.” But the reality is different: most Shopify stores that invest in full custom builds could achieve similar results with a premium theme plus 20–40% customization and save $50–120k.
At SPLIT Development, we only deliver full custom Shopify projects where custom work clearly generates a return on investment. This article is a practical guide to understand when full custom Shopify design pays off within 3–6 months — and when it’s simply burning budget.
By late 2025, Shopify themes have become incredibly powerful. Prestige, Impulse, Broadcast, Turbo, Warehouse and others cover 90–95% of common UX needs across beauty, fashion, lifestyle, and wellness brands.
Real growth today usually comes from:
Design alone no longer wins. Clarity, predictability, speed, and performance do.
Annual revenue → Recommended solution → Cost → Typical ROI
| Annual Revenue | Best Approach | Cost Range | ROI Timeline |
|---|---|---|---|
| <$3M | Premium theme + partial customization | $8k–25k | 1–3 months |
| $3–10M | Hybrid build (theme + 40–60% custom UX) | $25k–60k | 3–6 months |
| $10M+ | Full custom / Shopify Plus / Hydrogen | $80k–200k+ | 4–12 months |
This is the honest picture. That’s why SPLIT Development does not recommend full custom until the brand has already pushed a premium theme to its realistic limits.
AI-generated designs, personalization flows, product builders, complex bundles, multi-step PDPs.
Example: For Artificial Printer, we built a custom flow for AI-generated t-shirt designs. It increased engagement in the configurator and reduced friction in the ordering process.
Bridal, luxury beauty, wellness — verticals where UX and storytelling strongly influence perceived value and conversion.
Example: For The Bridal Gallery, custom navigation and modular PDP blocks improved how users explored a premium bridal catalog.
Multi-region setups, multi-currency, advanced content structures, localized experiences, and complex internationalization.
Advanced upsells, sampling logic, loyalty mechanics, bundles at checkout, or deep Shopify Plus workflows powered by Checkout Extensibility and Shopify Functions.
When a popular theme like Dawn or Impulse can no longer support the UX, speed, or content density you need without painful workarounds.
In these scenarios, investing in full custom makes sense because it directly removes growth bottlenecks.
You likely do not need a fully custom Shopify build if:
In 2025, the real “sweet spot” for most brands is: premium theme + targeted custom UX and CRO. This often delivers 90–95% of the impact of a full custom build, at a fraction of the cost, with much faster time-to-launch.
After a complete UX overhaul and a mobile-first PDP redesign, plus better performance, the client reported a 45% increase in conversion rate shortly after launch. View the project →
Modular PDPs and improved collection structure made it easier for shoppers to discover and compare premium products across multiple categories. View the project →
A custom step-by-step flow for AI-generated designs increased engagement and made the purchasing process clearer and more enjoyable. View the project →
A $4M/year brand approached us for a full custom build quote in the $90k+ range. After a UX and tech audit, it was clear they only needed a premium theme + ~30% custom work.
Result: around $70k saved, conversion rate up by 18%, and launch delivered significantly faster.
A wellness brand wanted a full Hydrogen storefront “because it’s the future.” We evaluated their metrics and proposed a hybrid solution: highly optimized theme + performance tuning + mobile UX improvements.
Result: roughly 4× faster launch, comparable performance metrics, and about $120k saved versus a full headless build.
If your brand truly needs full custom, it has to be modern and performance-driven, not just “visually unique.” Key elements that matter in late 2025:
Our principle is simple:
We build custom only where it makes money. In all other cases, we recommend a hybrid or theme-based solution.
For each project, we evaluate:
Only after that we recommend one of three paths: premium theme optimization, hybrid customization, or full custom.
Custom Shopify design in 2025 is a powerful growth lever — but only for brands that are truly ready for it.
The brands that win are those that:
If you want a clear, honest view of which path will bring the highest ROI for your store, SPLIT Development can run a UX and performance review of your Shopify store and give you a concrete action plan.
Making the right choice in a Shopify development agency is crucial. This article highlights what to consider — from experience and portfolio to client testimonials and project approach — ensuring you partner with an agency that aligns with your vision and goals.
Explore the decisive factors between WordPress and Shopify for your cosmetic online store. This article dives into ease of management, scalability, SEO capabilities, social media integration, and ownership costs to help you make an informed decision.
